But look at all the other random populations of it. That just means it hasn't been recorded. There is a good chance it was planted
That's a common misconception. The boxelder is only called ash leaved maple because of the similarity of the leaves. The ash is part of the Oleaceae family and the box elder is part of the Sapindaceae family. They really aren't related.
one already wood ya! the suspense is killing us!! Not seeing the tell tale red in the cross cut, but not necessarily seeing the classic pinhole look of the center like ash either.
I'm saying Box Elder, even after seeing no red in the rounds. I've cut several BE that had no red in them. The cambium/bark in your round looks like that of BE, not ash ...
Wait! Is ash in the maple family? EDIT: I posted the above before reading all the posts so this has been answered already.
I am still with you but I don't see either tree very often. Ash trees around here leaves don't look like those and like you said the bark doesn't either. But I don't see many of them. They exist around here just not a common tree I would say. But back to ash. When I can get it I grab it. I love that stuff. Splits easy , dries fast, and yall say it's decent BTUS (all I have cut is in my piles). I think the first one I cut is in this year's pile to burn though so we will see.
I was to busy to type it out the last few days, but Barcroftb nailed it. clemsonfor if it's not local to you, you get a pass.