That stinks, it is always nice to have a country butcher near by. Fortunately I have a ton to choose from, but I do live in somewhat of a rural area!
I visit Nells often, as well as A & W Meats here in T Town. I also like Myers Meat Market in Hanover!
I've always had good results with Nell's. Used them for the last couple years for hogs and beef. Recently switched to Godfreys for beef cause my BIL raises them and it's closer. I've heard the market in Manchester is pretty good too. Miller's maybe can't remember off hand.
My aunt loves millers, she buys most of her beef there. I have never heard of Godfreys, I will have to look them up.
Godfreys is on the the trail above Shrewsbury. Their is also another Godfrey over around Seven Valleys I think.