I'm looking for a site that sells replacement handles. Where do you all get yours? I found a site before that sold all types of tool handles but I can't remember what the name of the site. I'm looking for a framing hammer handle right now. I can't seem to find the correct size handle for the eye. Its a Stanley FatMax 22. I know its probably not much more to buy a new hammer but I like to repair stuff if I can. Also thought about making one.
It's better if you can find them at a local hardware store and check the sizing in person. That said, I've ordered from Whiskey River Art and Trading Co. and they have a good product. Their customer service will help you find the right size too.
Beaver Tooth also has some nice handles, but like Baldhornet said, House has a huge selection. When I work with house I usually pay the extra dough for , hand picked, unfinished and octagonal.